5th Circuit’s Methylene Chloride Ruling Upends EPA’s TSCA Risk Evaluations

The 5th Circuit’s unanimous Sept. 15 decision in East Fork Enterprises v. EPA vacated the agency’s risk management rule for methylene chloride, sharply faulting EPA’s approach to assessing the chemical’s risks under TSCA and, more broadly, the methods the agency has long used to evaluate existing chemicals. Legal experts say the ruling will ripple across EPA’s entire chemicals program, forcing the agency to revisit risk evaluations for methylene chloride and potentially other chemicals. The decision is the first to deeply probe key TSCA issues since Congress overhauled the law in 2016, echoing the 1991 Corrosion Proof Fittings ruling that blocked an asbestos ban and noting “Congress did not enact TSCA as a zero-risk statute.” Industry attorneys say EPA is unlikely to appeal, as the ruling aligns with the Trump EPA’s own draft framework rule on risk evaluation — potentially accelerating its finalization. With multiple TSCA risk management rules pending before various circuit courts, questions remain over possible circuit splits and whether EPA will need to renegotiate court-ordered deadlines. For more context, click here.